Tim,
I've heard good and bad with a lot of the aftermarket batteries... Some have really good luck and some with bad luck. The common thread with all seems to be the fit and seal of the batteries...
What I've read on another thread was some take apart their dead Canon batteries and swap the ends with their new aftermarket batteries... Which is what I will probably do with mine once I get my new ones.
I've been a hard core Canon user since buying my Canon AE-1 way back in the day... If money weren't an object, I'd buy the Canon battery all the time. But, unfortunately I'm a regular working guy like most and I've got to watch my dollars and cents...lol!
Thanks,
Larry